New Deli is praised as a cozy, affordable bakery and cafe offering high-quality pastries, standout croissants, and flavorful coffee, often described as a hidden gem. Customers appreciate its friendly staff, inventive flavor combinations, and good value, though some mention inconsistent opening hours. The establishment excels in baked goods, with particular favorites including almond croissants and pesto-tomato pastries, and offers a range of specialty drinks like matcha and açai bowls. Overall, it is well-loved for its inviting atmosphere, delicious offerings, and support of local, small-scale operations.