The reviews highlight a mix of positive and negative experiences with BBQ seafood stalls, particularly showcasing the appeal of stingray and other dishes. Many commend the freshness, flavor, and decent prices, especially noting the stall's long-standing reputation and good service. Conversely, some reviewers express dissatisfaction with small portion sizes, inconsistent quality, bland flavors, and long waiting times. Overall, the stall's offerings are appreciated for their taste and value by some, but others advise caution due to inconsistency and service issues.