Everton Creamery is praised for its wide variety of delicious, creamy ice creams and crispy waffles, making it a popular casual spot for desserts. Customers appreciate the friendly service, cozy ambiance, and high-quality flavors like pistachio, dark chocolate, and innovative options such as maoshan wang durian and alcohol-infused varieties. While some mention high prices and limited tasting options, the overall impression is positive, with many returning for the enjoyable experience and good value for premium offerings.