Edith Patisserie's reviews reflect a mix of appreciation for their diverse and appealing cake selection, which many find both delicious and visually attractive. Customers often praise the cozy ambiance, friendly staff, and quality of their baked goods, especially their brownies and matcha treats. However, repeated concerns include inconsistent food quality—cakes being dry or overly dense—and subpar service experiences, with some incidents of rudeness and inattentiveness from staff. Prices are also noted as high relative to the perceived value, and some reviews highlight issues with service professionalism and cleanliness. Overall, while loved for their variety and atmosphere, improvements are needed in food consistency and customer service.